This isn’t in relation to how Three Houses is written itself, but I’d like to point out that this reminds me of how so many of the Edel-stans create problems based on Edel’s gender out of thin air. Seriously.
Now, I won’t say that Three Houses doesn’t have some misogynistic writing tropes at all, given that most characters who suffer under “Teh Crest Systum” are women who are being treated as breeding stock and baragaining chips. But the writers didn’t make women in particular suffering this kind of abuse as a plot point to be intentionally recognized or thought about, cuz not once does anyone in the game think “huh, it sure is weird how women in particular are suffering this degree of abuse, and men aren’t.” Apparently Sylvain hating people for not liking him for his personality and Hanneman feeling a type of way for what his sister went through is some great equalizer.
But I digress; the point is, 3H doesn’t care about pointing out misogyny nor is anyone’s gender an inhibitor on their lives. But as I said, Edelstans will create these problems whole cloth, and slowly but surely act as if they’re real and canon. And then proceed to act as if they are pioneering a feminist plot through their support of Edel cuz “THIS POOR GIRL IS SO OPPRESSED!!!”
And... creating misogynistic problems from nothing and applying them to a piece of media that didn’t (deliberately) have any of said problems in the first place? Just so you can prop up your fav character? That’s really not feminist in the slightest IMO. And I’m not a woman so maybe it’s not my place to comment on that, but it just seems incredibly backwards and regressive.
foulserpent :
i like how when the fantasy genre gets Feminist it's still very often like:
-lightly misogynist fantasy setting as backdrop for plucky heroine who shows everyone that Girls Can Fight, with numerous 'huhhhh????????? a GIRL???????????????!!!!!!!" scenes (that might have been saying something new in like, the 80s latest) trying so hard to prove Girls Can Fight that you wonder why they arent just creating a setting where women have relative social equality to begin with.
-heavily misogynist fantasy setting as backdrop for story where the author ascribes misogyny to innate human sexual differences divorced from cultural construction (shockingly, 100% in line with exact ways western gender binary and womanhood is culturally constructed). heroine spends much time lamenting on this, having been directly imparted with the author's great wisdom on these matters. other women are mostly repressed or antagonistic to our heroine, who herself spends many paragraphs fantasizing about boring male leads due to author's beliefs about this being an innate physical drive and preoccupation of all women (which is lamented about). at absolutely no point is people sometimes having gay sex and relationships acknowledged as a thing that exists.
-the same as the above but author is approaching from a 'we are the daughters of witches you couldnt burn' kinda angle and is writing a manifesto against christianity and patriarchy that is more rigid and binaristic in its views on gender than an early middle ages christian peasant.
in average
are photos
are videos
are texts
are gifs
are audio