matilda was written for neil josten you can't change my mind
While listening to Harry's House, I realized that one of my favorite songs perfectly described one of my favorite characters. When something like this occasionally happens I lose my shit with happiness, and this time is not difficult because Matilda, by Harry Styles, perfectly encapsulates Neil in the beginning and throughout the book, and the bridge is the perfect transition to see how Neil is doing in the last book. So I decided (because it's not like I have a huge project for my history class) to analyze each line, verse, chorus and bridge of this wonderful song.
[Verse 1]
You were riding your bike to the sound of "It's No Big Deal”
And you're trying to lift off the ground on those old two wheels
Nothing 'bout the way that you were treated ever seemed especially alarming till now
So you tie up your hair and you smile like it's no big deal
This verse is showing how Neil, in the beginning of The Foxhole Court, acts like nothing is wrong and that he is, as we all know, fine. The second line can be interpreted as Neil being by himself and having to be his own “support system” or, simply how he had to get himself out of situations by himself. For the third line, it's pretty much self explanatory: Neil never experienced that unconditional love from neither of his biological parents. As for the last line it is really how Neil is in the start and for most of the trilogy, when he pretends that he is fine and doing perfectly okay.
[Chorus]
You can let it go
You can throw a party full of everyone you know
And not invite your family 'cause they never showed you love
You don't have to be sorry for leavin' and growin' up, mmm
Personally, after hearing the chorus I felt like Wymack is the one saying this to Neil. In The Raven King, when Neil says “Help me” and Wymack replies with “Let me”, it was so heartwarming but sad at the same time. Even though we didn't really see them have a deeper talk about what happened to Neil over break this chorus is very fitting of something Wymack would say because, not only does he know it would comfort Neil, but because it’s true and he knows Neil needs to hear it.
[Verse 2]
Matilda, you talk of the pain like it's all alright
But I know that you feel like a piece of you's dead insidе
You showed me a power that is strong еnough to bring sun to the darkest days
It's none of my business, but it's just been on my mind
When I first made the connection between the song and the books, I will admit that my andreil-fangirl self was adamant that Andrew is the one “singing it”, but with further inspection I strongly feel like Wymack is the one talking to Neil again.
We have those moments when Wymack knows something is wrong with Neil but when he confronts Neil, he is told that he will have an explanation of everything after finals. Wymak knows Neil is in pain but he talks about it “like it's all alright”, or fine. The second line goes back to when I said Wymack knows Neil isn’t fine and, just like the last line says, “It's none of my business, but it's just been on my mind”.
The fourth line in this verse is very related to the foxes. Before Neil the team was split into two groups, it was a “dark” time for the foxes. When Neil arrives, the line between the monsters and the rest of the team starts blurring and it gets to the point where they all can actually talk and even go on a vacation together. Let's say that Neil “brings the sun” to the foxes who were living in darkness.
[Chorus]
You can let it go
You can throw a party full of everyone you know
And not invite your family 'cause they never showed you love
You don't have to be sorry for leavin' and growin' up
You can see the world, following the seasons
Anywhere you go, you don't need a reason
'Cause they never showed you love
You don't have to be sorry for doin' it on your own
I already talked about the first four lines so i'll be focusing on the last four.
As we know Neil went to many cities and a few countries, he saw many cultures and seasons. There's not a lot to say other than the fact that the chorus in the song is very much about his past but, what I really like is the last line where “Harry points” out that Neil was on his own. Even when his mom was alive he was alone.
[Bridge]
You're just in time, make your tea and your toast
You framed all your posters and dyed your clothes, ooh
You don't have to go
You don't have to go home
Oh, there's a long way to go
I don't believe that time will change your mind
In other words, I know they won't hurt you anymore
As long as you can let them go
The first five lines of the bridge sound like an explanation of Neil packing and changing his life over time because he had to move far away from whatever place he was (a bunch of time). The last two lines hurt me so much because it feels like something Andrew would say to Neil when they go to the roof, “I know they won't hurt you anymore / As long as you can let them go”. Neil doesn’t have to worry anymore because he is safe now, and once he starts moving on - like when he legally changes his name to Neil Josten - he will be able to start the new life he desires so badly.
[Chorus]
You can let it go
You can throw a party full of everyone you know
You can start a family who will always show you love
You don't have to be sorry for doin' it on your own
You can let it go
You can throw a party full of everyone you know
You can start a family who will always show you love
You don't have to be sorry, no
This is the end of the song, and it matches up with the end of the last book, The King's Men. instead of “And not invite your family 'cause they never showed you love”, now the words are “You can start a family who will always show you love”. And that is exactly what Neil does. The foxes go from being simply his teammates from being his family, to being the people he loves unconditionally - and as we know, they also love Neil with everything they have. By the end of the book Neil loves his life and is finally, truly happy.
💌 thank you for reading! <3 And before anyone says anything, I just wanted to let yall that I love this new album and, YES! I do know this wasn't written for Neil but it's just a cool connection that I made so that I could combine my two favorite things.